A Dangerous Crossing by Rachel Rhys

“On a boat like this … everyone is running away from something.” (p. 65)

dangerous crossing

Miserably, I have been in a bit of a reading slump for most of the year. Not the kind of slump where I’ve been unable to read for extended periods; the kind where I’m ploughing on but very few books are truly engaging me. I have a feeling that my tastes have changed a little of late and that my TBR pile needs to be updated to reflect this. Something I shall investigate further …

Anyway, as soon I read a brief synopsis of A Dangerous Crossing I knew it would be The One. The One to shed some (albeit) temporary light on my currently rather dingy reading life.

And I wasn’t wrong, even though it turned out that this wasn’t quite the book I was expecting.

A Dangerous Crossing is billed as a mystery novel, as a cross between Agatha Christie and Patricia Highsmith. Whilst I can see some similarities to the latter, any comparison to Christie is terribly misleading. I think it’s a marketing ploy to hook readers – and I can’t deny that it worked because it certainly reeled me in. But it could backfire terribly with readers expecting a Golden Age-style mystery and becoming disengaged with this rich piece of fiction.

 A Dangerous Crossing is less a mystery than it is a stunning work of historical fiction. It opens in the summer of 1939 and follows former maid and waitress Lily Shepherd on her five-week journey across the ocean to a new life – albeit one still involving domestic servitude – in Australia.

The novel crackles with tension. It opens with Lily’s ship, the Orontes, docking in Australia. A woman is led off the ship, under arrest. We thus begin our journey with Lily knowing that, by the time she arrives at her destination, two people will have died on board the ship and Europe will be at war.

So there is a mystery here: who is the woman in the fox fur stole who we see under arrest in the Prologue? Most of the women we encounter throughout the novel wear said stole at some point so there is an intense kind of a Pass the Parcel going on, particularly in the latter stages. Whose shoulders will the stole be draped around when the ‘music’ stops? The waiting is tense and the answer doesn’t disappoint …

But the mystery isn’t the central focus. What Rachel Rhys does centre the novel around, and skilfully evokes, is the idea of the ship as a liminal space. The characters find themselves between their old lives and their new beginnings, neither the people they were back home or yet the people they will become. Moreover, the whole world is suspended between peace and war:

All over the ship there is the strangest sense of being in limbo between what is real and what isn’t, between the departure and the arrival, between the threat of war and whatever comes next. (p. 320)

More gripping than the underlying mystery are Lily’s relationships with her fellow passengers: the Jewish refugee Maria, the fascist George Price, the scandalous upper class American couple Max and Eliza Campbell and the middle class brother and sister Helena and Edward Fletcher, who becomes Lily’s love interest.

Lily quickly realises that, on board the ship, the class boundaries that rigidly governed her life back home have been broken down as all society merges as one on the Orontes:

Such a blurring of lines here – the guests dancing with the staff. But then again, is it any more strange than her being here, with the sort of people to whom she used to serve tea, whose houses she once cleaned. (p. 131)

Clear-eyed and level-headed, Lily realises that this situation, this brief sip of a life of luxury, will be temporary: “she will go back to her world and they will go back to theirs and life will be once again divided into its correct boxes” (p. 315).

But what the novel seems to ask is ‘does this necessarily have to be the case?’ Could these social boundaries be permanently surmounted once the passengers reach their destination and build their lives anew? Do they have to once again be divided into ‘master’ and ‘servant’? Doe sthe war really have to make them ‘ally’ and ‘enemy’? In short, do these “correct boxes” have to be a part of this new existence or could the characters start again without them? It is this – not ‘who is the lady in the fox fur stole?’ – that is the central question in A Dangerous Crossing.

This is a beautifully written and evocative novel. It is by turns tense and tender and always wonderfully atmospheric, as we follow Lily to Australia via Gibraltar and Egypt. And because it has a clear message about unity and understanding those we perceive as ‘different’ to us, A Dangerous Crossing seems highly relevant to the times too.

Laura by Vera Caspary

41KLeoFGBxL._SX324_BO1,204,203,200_

Published in 1942, Laura has all the ingredients of a classic forties’ noir.

It has atmosphere in abundance: the majority of the action seems to take place during dramatic thunderstorms or torrential downpours.

It has a gripping central mystery with a beautiful ‘femme fatale’ at its heart. Laura Hunt, a New York advertising executive, is found shot dead on her own doorstep, her face obliterated by the blast.

It has a cynical detective with a well-hidden heart of gold (Detective Mark McPherson).

And it has the whip smart, wisecracking dialogue one has come to expect of the genre:

Bony hands gripped the table.

‘Let’s have another drink.’

I suggested Courvoisier.

‘You order. I can’t pronounce it.’ (Caspary, 1942)

These elements alone would make this novel a must read. But, for me, Laura has a little something extra and that’s a discussion of gender politics that is still relevant today.

In Laura Hunt, we have a heroine who struggles to balance a burgeoning career with her personal life. Described as having ‘a man’s job and a man’s worries’, Laura’s status rankles with her fiancé Shelby Carpenter in particular:

‘When I went to work for Rose, Rowe and Sanders, I made thirty-five dollars a week. She was getting a hundred and seventy-five.’ He hesitated, the colour of his cheeks brightened to the tones of an overripe peach. ‘Not that I resented her success. She was so clever that I was awed and respectful. And I wanted her to make as much as she could; believe that Mr McPherson. But it’s hard on a man’s pride. I was brought up to think of women … differently.’ (Caspary 1942)

That these themes still – sadly – resonate today makes this gripping, atmospheric thriller even more fascinating. Definitely one that should be more widely read.

The Heart of Blade Duology by Sherry Thomas

img_3067

Ying-ying and Leighton are the stars of My Beautiful Enemy, the ‘main course’ of Sherry Thomas’s Heart of Blade duology. We first meet them – long before they meet each other – in the prequel, The Hidden Blade.

Set in the late 19th century, this novel examines how the couple’s childhood experiences shape them. In Peking, we see Ying-ying take centre stage in a wuxia narrative: a traditional Chinese tale that typically follows martial artists of almost superhuman abilities. In Ying-ying’s case, her life changes irrevocably when her nanny turns out to be one such martial arts hero and takes her as a pupil. Well. That would have livened up Mary Poppins. Meanwhile, back in England, we watch in horror as Leighton Atwood’s wicked uncle destroys his childhood before pursuing him to China, where Leighton escapes in search of a beloved family friend.

I would have appreciated a greater sense of an origin story here: more on Ying-ying’s training would have been good as she seems to go from 0 to 60 rather quickly. That said, The Hidden Blade is tremendous fun: fist-pumpingly feminist with a great cast of supporting characters and an utterly breath-taking action sequence at the end.

img_3068

Although it is meant to be ‘the main event’ as it were, My Beautiful Enemy disappoints in comparison. We catch up with Ying-ying (now known as Catherine Blade) and Leighton just as they reconnect, eight years after their last meeting. This encounter is rather awkward because Catherine had thought she’d killed Leighton after their love affair soured and he betrayed her. It’s such a pain when that happens at formal functions.

Thomas’s writing is top notch throughout both novels, and My Beautiful Enemy certainly has its fun moments – none more fun than this:

She lowered into a crouch, then leaped up atop the table, balanced upon an upside-down teacup. (My Beautiful Enemy, p. 189)

Yes, you read that correctly. Ying-ying executes a perfect handstand on a teacup. That’s certainly how I like to conclude breakfast.

Dining table gymnastics aside, this novel is often rather dull. We spend most of the prequel dying for Ying-ying and Leighton to meet but their romance seems oddly bloodless in the end. Additionally, the finale of My Beautiful Enemy is incredibly weak. I am talking Scooby Doo levels of silliness and subtlety.

All in all, these are well-written novels that skilfully evoke both period and place and boast a fantastic heroine. The prequel is by far the stronger book, however, with the main event being married by a limp and unconvincing romance.

Six Tudor Queens: Katherine of Aragon, The True Queen by Alison Weir

img_2478

The True Queen is the first in a projected six-book series focusing on each of Henry VIII’s wives. A well-trodden path indeed. However, Alison Weir, also a well-known historian, promises to examine new evidence and to consider this oft-fictionalised period from different angles.

In actual fact, I didn’t find much that was new in this volume. What I did find, though, is that the level of detail Weir includes here is so great that she frequently manages to be illuminating anyway. This is a potted, fictionalised biography of Katherine from her arrival in England in 1501 to her death in 1536. The novel is so throughly researched that Weir is able to fully realise events and flesh out characters that other fictional accounts have often just skipped over. Moreover, the way she chooses to depict Katherine’s marriages to the doomed Prince Arthur and to Henry feels very convincing.

As he opened the door to leave, she found she could no longer control her emotions and broke down completely, emitting great, tearing sobs that sounded like an animal in pain. All those years together, all the love that had been between them, the children they had conceived and lost, the joys, the sorrow, the things they had shared … They had been one flesh, and now Henry wanted to break them asunder and end it all. It was more than she could bear.

I particularly admired the fact that Weir didn’t impose 21st century values on Katherine in a bid to make her more relatable to contemporary readers. Katherine is very much a woman of the 16th century here, but we feel sympathy for her plight regardless.

That said, Weir’s prose can be dry and overly simplistic and her skills as a novelist are middling at best, something apparent in her rather emotionless depiction of Thomas More’s demise. She edges towards psychological realism at times, but too often the novel drags and feels like one of those stilted, lightly dramatised TV documentaries.

I would say that there’s just enough here to make the novel worth reading. But The True Queen doesn’t add a huge amount to existing knowledge and understanding of its subject. The second novel in the series, focusing of course on Anne Boleyn, is scheduled for release on May 18th. I’m certainly interested to see what insights Weir can bring to this topic, given that there are more fictional accounts of Anne than of Katherine.

Margot and Me by Juno Dawson

31574295

This is the first Juno Dawson book I’ve read and, really, where on earth have I been?! Margot and Me is by turns hilarious, heartbreaking, gripping, warm and wise.

Our narrator is 15-year-old Fliss. We meet her just as she and her mum, who is recovering from cancer, are making the temporary move from London to Wales. They’re staying with Fliss’s grandmother, Margot, who isn’t exactly the warm and fuzzy type. As sparks fly between the generations, Fliss decides that she hates her cold-hearted grandmother.

However, when Fliss stumbles across Margot’s teenage diary, kept during the Second World War, she gets an unexpected insight into the events that shaped the older woman, and unearths family secrets into the bargain:

OK, I have to look or I’ll explode with curiosity. Margot at sixteen! I can hardly imagine it: some people just come out of the womb aged forty and she’s one of them. I’ll read just a tiny bit.

From this point, the novel switches between the two narratives: Margot’s wartime experiences, which are vividly rendered, and Fliss’s (often belly laugh-inducing) responses, interspersed with her experiences getting to grips with life at a new school. The voices of both Margot and Fliss are incredibly authentic and both narratives are equally involving.

Dawson’s writing is both funny and insightful. Her portrayal of serious illness is refreshingly unsentimental and unflinching. Along with Fliss and Margot, there is an endearing cast of supporting characters and Dawson’s depiction of Fliss’s burgeoning friendships is both hilarious and moving.

Fliss’s narrative is set in the late nineties, when I myself was a teenager. This brought the added bonus of a blissful bubble of nostalgia, evoking memories of things I hadn’t thought of for years (Vanilla Kisses Impulse! Kappa Slappers (I confess, I was one!)! Party of Five! Pop out hairbrushes from the Body Shop! Fido Dido ring binders! Virgin Megastore! Freddie Prince Jr.! Helen Daniels and her tragic demise!).

Margot and Me was one of the books that I felt I had lived rather than read. I will issue a weepie warning, though, but there is plenty of wit and warmth to make up for it.

Little Deaths by Emma Flint

41roiokj5ml-_sx323_bo1204203200_

Emma Flint’s debut novel is based on the real-life case of Alice Crimmins who, in 1965, was accused of murdering her young son and daughter. The case has inspired several fictional retellings, including Mary Higgins Clark’s Where Are The Children?

In Flint’s hands, Alice Crimmins becomes Ruth Malone and the gender politics of the case come to the fore. Ruth exposes the paradoxical and hypocritical way in which society views women. In a world where “nobody got time for someone else’s sadness”, Ruth recognises the need to present a polished and presentable exterior for risk of being labelled hysterical and/or undesirable: “She had to keep the wrong part of her, the messy part, hidden.”

But, although society demands this performance from Ruth, it also condemns her for it. Her regard for her own appearance, her fondness for male company, the fact that she tired of the constraints of domesticity – not only are these traits seen as incompatible with her role as a mother, they are signs of her guilt:

‘Bitch did it. No doubt.’ That was a guy with the nose of a drinker and a drooping eyelid that looked like a wink. ‘You seen how she looks coming in and out of the station – face all made up and hair done. She’s never cried for ’em. Not once.’

Flint’s examination of this issue is interesting, but once the novel has made its point, it has nothing else to do but to keep on making it. There is something a little hollow about Little Deaths, despite Flint’s atmospheric depiction of 1960s Queens. Large swathes of the book drag terribly. I think part of the problem is that, most of the time, readers are kept an arm’s length from Ruth. There is the odd striking, beautifully written depiction of her grief, but most of the time Ruth is remote and the novel lacks an emotional core.

This is certainly not supplied by Pete Wonicke, the journalist who becomes fixated on discovering the ‘real Ruth’ beyond the tawdry tabloid headlines he is originally charged to write. His obsession with Ruth is never fully explained and his actions towards the end of the novel are far-fetched to say the least. Indeed, the whole finale verges on daftness.

Overall, whilst there is some interesting meditation on gender politics here, there is little else. A bit of a disappointment, then, but there is enough insight and good writing here to draw me to Flint’s future work.

Good Me Bad Me by Ali Land

As I look down at their beautiful faces I remember a story I read. A Native American tale where the Cherokee tells his grandson there’s a battle between two wolves in all of us. One is evil, the other good. The boy asks him, which wolf wins? The Cherokee tells him, the one you feed. (p. 56)

25365530

2017 seems to have brought with it a truckload of astonishingly assured and exciting debut novels. One of the most hyped of the bunch is Ali Land’s thriller, Good Me Bad Me, which I reckon just about lives up to its billing. It is a compulsive read, a true page-turner, even if it does stumble a little bit at the end.

Unlike other examples of the genre, much of Good Me Bad Me‘s horror and darkness lies right on the surface, rather than being buried beneath, a mystery to slowly unravel. This makes the novel more of a vivid and disturbing psychological portrait than a psychological thriller. But it is gripping and compulsive regardless.

The character we get this vivid and disturbing psychological portrait of is 15-year-old Milly Barnes. We know, more or less from the start, that Milly’s mother is a serial killer who abused her for years and is accused of murdering nine children. Milly is awaiting her mother’s trial, having finally reported her to the police. Despite this, and despite her awareness of her mother’s guilt and monstrousness, Milly’s bond with her mother remains:

… the person I want to run from is also the person I want to run to. (p. 45)

Land, with her sparse, direct, almost staccato prose, deftly explores this conflict. Moreover, by placing Milly with a foster family who aren’t exactly the Waltons, Land raises the question: who can truly help a child this damaged?

Milly is a compelling narrator and her voice rings very true. Too often novelists depicting teenagers and their patterns of speech get it badly wrong, but Land has a fine ear. Milly isn’t just damaged; she’s also intelligent, witheringly sarcastic, observant, funny and kind. And every so often … menacing, threatening and terrifying. What is interesting about this novel is that the threat and the tension come not from any external force but from Milly, from her internal conflict: which ‘wolf’ will she feed? Will society, circumstance and her surroundings give her a choice?

I was also fascinated by Land’s examination of the darkness in women. Not only do we have a female serial killer here, but the novel repeatedly highlights that females have the potential not just to be “Sugar and spice” but “all things” (p. 290).

Without giving too much away, I did find the ending of the novel disappointing. Land seems to take the obvious thriller route right at the close and I feel that something a bit more nuanced and ambiguous would have served the novel – and the multi-faceted Milly – far better.

That aside, Good Me Bad Me is a disturbing, real and unputdownable novel that heralds the emergence of a gifted new writer.